When Things Get Messy, Policies are Your Best Friend

Hannah
2 min readApr 24, 2024

--

Picture this: Susan, a café owner, gets a formal complaint — one employee accuses another of really inappropriate behaviour. It’s awkward, it’s tense, and Susan has no clue where to start. This is where a nightmare scenario begins for a lot of businesses… and it’s totally avoidable.

See, the thing about workplace investigations is that nobody ever plans to need one. But when those serious issues crop up — harassment, bullying, the really nasty stuff — having clear HR policies in place is your lifeline. It’s NOT just about staying legally compliant (though that’s important too!). It’s about making the process as fair and smooth as humanly possible for everyone involved.

So, what makes a good investigation policy? Here’s the gist:

  • Your policies should spell out what ISN’T okay (discrimination, harassment, all that bad stuff). It’s also where you outline how employees can safely report issues and who they go to. Think of it as setting expectations upfront.
  • Sometimes, going with an outside workplace investigator is the smartest play. Why? It removes any whisper of bias. If you’re equipped to handle things internally, your policies need to address fairness for both the accuser and the accused.
  • Guarantee that people feel safe to come forward. Respecting everyone’s privacy throughout the process is non-negotiable.
  • Don’t just write those policies and forget them! Making sure everyone is aware of them (new hires especially) and updating them regularly is key.

Okay, but why does any of this REALLY matter?

Messy investigations damage morale, lead to good employees walking out the door, and yeah, can get you in hot water legally. Proactive policies make the whole process less of a disaster.

Honestly, sometimes professional help with either HR policies or handling the investigation itself is the smartest investment you can make. It’s not about admitting you can’t handle it; it’s about doing things the right way to protect your business in the long run.

--

--